Skip to main content

My Favorite Dark Brown Hair Color Brand: Clairol Natural Instincts

I know it's only been a short time since my last color application but I was really hating the mousey light red-brown with now lighter roots and darker ends. eSalon's color rinse seemed to have dried out my hair and left me with some increased unevenness in overall color. I was feeling desperate for a change and decided to put more color in my hair, bringing it down a notch to try and get back that healthy look and feel. I had no idea what brand I would pick, but on a whim, picked a non-permanent color at the grocery store (total impulse buy).

Clairol Natural Instincts Dark Brown #28 caught my attention. When I was younger, I used this brand instead of permanent color to appease my dad, who hated the idea of me coloring my hair and I recall my mom trying it once or twice. Since it's not permanent, I felt comfortable going darker. With permanent color, I'm always afraid that dark brown will come out black. With Natural Instincts ammonia-free color, I took the risk without fear.
Before Natural Instincts Dark Brown 
Instructions for Natural Instincts were fairly typical. With this product, you're supposed to color on damp hair, so I just spritzed mine before coloring. To achieve a natural look on my currently uneven hair color, I did the following:
  1. Applied color from root to about 1/3 the way down the hair shaft, beginning at the front and working toward the back.
  2. After waiting 5 minutes, I added color halfway down.
  3. After another 5 minutes, I brushed in some of the color through the bottom 1/3 of my hair, but leaving it mostly as it was.
  4. Rinsed after a total of 15 minutes, applying the conditioning treatment that came in the box.

Since I bought "dark brown" rather than specifically a cool or warm brown, I wasn't sure what I'd get. Once applied, my hair looked like it was coated in a dark reddish brown dye.

Applying the color was easy enough. It's a liquid color, so I had a little dripping, but nothing difficult to clean up. The bottle was easy to hold compared to Olia's applicator and the smell wasn't as potent as Nice n' Easy's.

After rinsing, my hair felt a little rough. I didn't have a lot of shedding, which is awesome, but I was worried about dryness. Thankfully, after using the Natural Instincts Color Treat conditioner (comes with the coloring kit), my hair felt amazing - super soft and smooth!

For me, the real test of a home color kit, is the resulting color and condition of my hair. I was really floored by how natural my color came out. It's incredibly close to my natural shade and I love how well everything matched up with the sections I left untouched. It's like there are several rich brown tones throughout and it shimmers in the sunlight. My hair looks and feels way more healthy than before I colored. As soon as it dried, I ran to my husband and said, "you have to touch my hair!" I also texted my sister this picture right away since she loves to color and needs to try this asap.

My Natural Instincts Dark Brown After Shot
The real test will be whether this color actually lasts 28 shampoos, which for me would be a long time. I'll be pleased if I can go 6 weeks between coloring and since I really want to keep this color, I'm crossing my fingers. I've already ordered a 3-pack on Amazon. So it's not just that I like this color, I love it!

In two weeks, I'm supposed to use a color refresher that deposits color pigments in my hair. This little packet came in the box and my guess is that's how I'll get the full 28 shampoos. Fine by me!

What you should know is that when I visited the Natural Instincts website, I couldn't find Dark Brown 28 among the color options. They offer 27 liquid shades and 8 creme shades, plus 3 that specifically help with brassiness, but none looked like the one I bought. Thankfully I can buy it online, but I'm worried it's been discontinued.

While I love this color, I found I'd need two boxes if I was coloring my whole head. I barely had enough for the 2/3 or so of my hair I did color. If you have long or thick hair, plan for two boxes. It's so affordable that I really don't mind buying two.

Just to be clear about how awesome my hair looks, check out the before and after side-by-side:

My hair is shinier and healthier, and the color is more rich and luminous. When I visit my sister at college this weekend, I'm taking her to buy some Natural Instincts hair color. 

Curious about my other hair color experiences? Check out more of my hair color posts!


Popular posts from this blog

Switching from Olay Regenerist to L'Oreal RevitaLift

I've been using Olay Regenerist DNA Superstructure UV Cream for years now. I love the SPF 25 (it's now 30) the thick moisturizing quality, and how fresh my skin feels once it's absorbed. It's really thick, so it tends to need more time before I put on foundation, and it does leave my skin a touch lighter than it is in real life. The sunscreen ingredients mean this moisturizer smells just like traditional sun protection, and even a bit like my daughter's diaper cream (ick), but I know it's doing it's job and I've been really happy with it. I intended to buy some more during a trip to Walmart today, but L'Oreal RevitaLift Triple Power Day Lotion had a $2 off coupon attached, and the base price was less than the Olay product, so I took a chance and bought  the RevitaLift instead. L'Oreal's bottle is prettier with a similar pump mechanism. Like Olay, the product is in an opaque container, which helps keep the contents from being af

Garnier Olia Hair Color Review

BzzAgent sent me a coupon to try Garnier Olia haircolor and I was super excited to try a new color. Anyone who knows me knows that I've been coloring my hair since I was 13 years old. I've tried many shades from bright blue, purple, and fire engine red to pricey complex process salon dye jobs. I've stuck to mostly brown shades for the past couple of years and wanted a change. Most of my adult life, I've used either reddish tint or bolder rusty reds, so it seemed like a fun idea to go back to that for a while. Honestly, it was a little challenging to pick a shade I wanted to try because my experience with box color "light" and "medium" seems different from the example photos on Olia boxes. The brown and red shades look darker than what I would call "light," for example. At Walmart, there were 14 of the 24 Olia shades in stock, which narrowed down my choice. Since I was fearful of trying any light colors in case they were too light for Hair Color Review

It's now May 2014 and since my original review, I've had a chance to fly out to eSalon and see how orders are processed, learn the right way to apply color, and find out the differences between box color and eSalon color.  I learned a lot and have a totally different perspective now and would definitely recommend giving eSalon a try. When you order from eSalon, be sure to upload a current, well-lit photo of your hair and don't hesitate to ask their color experts for advice. The eSalon team are experts. Let them help you find the right shade and apply color correctly. It's a learning process if you're used to box color products. Last August, I tried  eSalon . At the time, I found the color was fine in that it was even and matched what I had seen online for that shade, but it wasn't really what I was going for. eSalon's customer service was helpful, with a colorist calling to explain how their product differs from what I buy in-store and the risks of g